Welcome to I Love NY Pizza in Alpharetta
At I Love NY Pizza, located at 980 Birmingham Road, Alpharetta, GA, we bring the taste of New York straight to your table. Our restaurant serves authentic New York–style pizza and Italian-American favorites that families and friends love. Whether you want a slice, a full pie, or a hearty pasta dish, we make it fresh every day. Our goal is to make your visit or order simple, convenient, and enjoyable.
Our Classics & Specialties
We offer a wide range of dishes for everyone. From classic pizzas to specialty pies, our menu also includes pasta, calzones, wings, and fresh salads. If you’re looking for a full meal, you can enjoy our desserts and drinks alongside your favorite pizza. Every dish is made with fresh ingredients and prepared with care to make your meal complete.
Authentic New York Pizza You Can Trust
Our pizzas are made with thin, handmade crusts and high-quality toppings, just like the ones in New York. Our chefs have mastered recipes passed down through generations, giving every pizza the authentic flavor people love. Beyond pizza, our versatile menu offers something for everyone, from wings and calzones to salads and pasta dishes.
Easy Ordering for Any Occasion
Getting your favorite meal from I Love NY Pizza is easy. You can dine in, take out, or order delivery straight to your home. Planning a gathering? We offer catering so your guests can enjoy our pizza, pasta, and more. You can also make a reservation to save your spot at our Alpharetta restaurant. No matter the occasion, we make it simple to enjoy great food.
A Look at Our Fresh Pizzas & More
See our gallery to discover the handmade pizzas, pasta, wings, and salads we serve. Each dish is prepared fresh and ready to enjoy with family or friends.
Book Your Table Today
Enjoy a relaxed dining experience at I Love NY Pizza Milton. Whether it’s a casual meal with family, a night out with friends, or a special celebration, we’re ready to host you. Please fill out the form below to request your table, and we’ll confirm your reservation promptly.
Catering Made Easy for Any Event
Planning a party or gathering? I Love NY Pizza makes catering simple with fresh New York-style pizzas, wings, pasta, salads, and more. Perfect for small or large groups, every dish is made with care and ready to share. Ordering is easy—call ahead, order online, or pick up at our Alpharetta location. Let us handle the food and make your next event delicious and stress-free.
Family-Friendly Atmosphere
I Love NY Pizza is more than a restaurant—it’s a place where people feel at home. Our casual, family-friendly environment makes it easy to enjoy a meal with friends or family. We focus on serving great food in a warm, welcoming space where everyone can relax and enjoy their favorite dishes.
Visit Us in Alpharetta or Order Today
We are open every day from 10 AM to 9 PM, ready to serve you and your family.
Whether you want to:
Dine in and enjoy a meal at our Alpharetta location
Take out for a quick and easy meal
Order delivery straight to your home
Plan a catered event for friends, family, or work
I Love NY Pizza makes it simple. Come visit us at 980 Birmingham Road, Alpharetta, GA, or place your order online to enjoy authentic New York-style pizza at home.
What our guests are saying
Delicious pizza delicious food great delivery service. We don’t eat in the restaurant, but we get takeout all the time❣️❣️❣️ thin crust pizza my favorite❣️❣️❣️ great service great staff. We’ve been getting takeout and delivery here since we moved here from Los Angeles and they are great❣️❣️❣️
Carin B.
We went with my family and we were very pleased. The taste and taste of the pizza was very good. The employees were also very polite :) We added it to our favorite places list :)
Seyda B.
I just moved nearby and had heard nice remarks about their pizza. I ordered a takeout and it was ready on time. It was hot even when we had arrived home. It was the best pizza I’ve had yet and the flavor was just unique and authentic. The best surprise was eating the garlic knots. Huge and soft and so much flavor.
Davey B.
Featuring
Dine-In
Takeout
Delivery
Catering
Reservations
Outdoor Seating
I Love NY Pizza Rewards
Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food!
Frequently Asked Questions
What are you known for?
We are known for American Food, Lasagna, Chicken Salad, Pasta, Cannoli, Margherita Pizza, Baked Ziti, Veggie Pizza, Fries, Caprese, Fettuccine Alfredo, BBQ Chicken Pizza, Subs, Spaghetti, French Fries, Garlic Bread, Italian Food, Dessert, Greek Salad, Hawaiian Pizza, Meat Pizza, Salads, Grilled Chicken, Garlic Knots, White Pizza, Burgers, Sicilian Pizza, Tiramisu, Mozzarella Sticks, Stromboli, Antipasto Salad, Grilled Chicken Salad, Steak and Cheese Sub, Cheesecake, Vegetarian Food, Meatballs, Calzone, Caprese Salad, Ravioli, Cheese Pizza, BBQ, Caesar Salad, Wings, and Penne Alla Vodka
Where are you located?
We are located in Alpharetta, GA at 980 Birmingham Rd
What areas do you serve?
We serve the following areas: Birmingham, Milton, Batesville, Union Hill, Fields Crossroads, Arnold Mill, Holbrook, Carmichael Crossroads, Hickory Flat, Crabapple, Free Home, Avery, Lathemtown, Alpharetta, Orange, Macedonia, Webb, Roswell, Drew, Harmony.
Our location
